Main image
Mar
4
posted by Sharon, on March 4, 2009 at 1:27 pm

by Sharon Udasin
Staff Writer

Israel’s offensive in the Gaza Strip ended more than a month ago, but for two college campuses in the snow-flushed mountains of central New York, the aftershocks from the war with Hamas continue to reverberate.

In the latest tremors, the most recent edition of the Ithaca College alumni magazine ICView, featured ’08 grad Emily McNeill’s eyewitness account of Israeli settler violence in Palestinian land. It sparked a campus-wide battle among students, faculty and alumni. 

Meanwhile, two miles north at Cornell, the formerly peaceful Muslim and pro-Israel organizations broke what had been an increasingly friendly dialogue with a series of antagonistic rallies and protests.

“Ithaca is a very liberal town — it’s sort of in its own little bubble,” said Shai Akabas, president of the Cornell Israel Public Affairs Committee. “There are more people who lean to the far left side of the political spectrum, and some of those people tend to take more stances against Israel. That may to some extent spur the far-left student population to take action.”

Last month, a group of Cornell students decked the campus Arts Quad with signs condemning Israel’s war on Gaza and 1,300 black flags to represent the dead from both sides, The Cornell Daily Sun reported. Cornell’s Islamic Alliance for Justice did not organize the Feb. 9 protest, though some members participated in the display, its president, Tara Malik, told The Sun. But by that same afternoon, many of those same signs had been vandalized and stolen. Continue reading…

3 Comments

  1. Rebecca
    08/03/2009

    Ms. Udasin, why didn’t you interview a much wider range of people at Ithaca College for your story published in the Jewish Week? It’s entirely false to talk about a “campus-wide battle” at Ithaca College over the publication of Emily McNeill’s article in ICView, and it’s equally ridiculous to headline your article, “Intifada, Ithaca Style.” To use the term “intifada” implies violent confrontations in which people may be killed. No such physical confrontations have occurred at either of the campuses here.

  2. 11/03/2009

    Hi, just to let you know — writers don’t create their own headlines — in fact, we often have no idea what they will be until they’re published. Editors always write the headlines.

  3. Rebecca
    22/03/2009

    Thanks for letting me know about who wrote the headline. I’m not a journalist, so I didn’t know that. My objection is deeper, however, than the headline. Why didn’t you interview more people at Ithaca College? It seems that you spoke to one faculty member and a couple of students. You didn’t talk to anybody in the administration, as far as I could tell, to get their point of view. I teach at Ithaca College and I can tell you that there was no “campus-wide” battle. The article gives a very distorted picture of the mood on campus by failing to let the reader know about the variety of views at the college on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Leave a Reply